Price vs. Value, DCF Valuation, FCFF/FCFE, WACC & CAPM
Distinguish market price from intrinsic value, learn the three valuation approaches, and master DCF mechanics—DDM, FCFE vs. FCFF, CAPM Cost of Equity, WACC, and Terminal Value.
Official Learning Objectives Covered in This Lesson
Price vs. Value, DCF Valuation, FCFF/FCFE, WACC & CAPM
Suppose you are buying a flat in Mumbai. The seller quotes Rs. 1.50 Crore—that is the Price. Before signing a cheque, you check what monthly rent the flat can earn over the next 20 years and what similar flats in the building sold for—that estimate of true worth is Value. Chapter 10 (Valuation Principles) is tied with Chapter 8 as the highest-weightage fundamental chapter in the SEBI RA exam (12 marks!), and mastering it turns you from a news-follower into a real Research Analyst.
LO 10.1 Price vs. Intrinsic Value, Sources of Value & Valuation Approaches
Price vs. Value: Art Meets Science
Two legendary quotes in the NISM workbook capture the soul of investing:
- Warren Buffett: "Price is what you pay, and Value is what you get."
- Seth Klarman: "In capital markets, price is set by the most panicked seller; value, which is determined by cash flows and assets, is not."
Price is visible every second on NSE/BSE screens. Intrinsic Value is an analyst's reasoned estimate of what a business is truly worth. Because future sales, profits, and interest rates are uncertain, valuation is both an art and a science—there is never one "exact magic rupee number," which is why analysts present multiple scenarios (bull, base, bear).
Six Key Reasons Valuations Are Required: (1) Buying a business/stock, (2) Selling a business/stock, (3) Mergers & Acquisitions, (4) Giving owners a sense of business worth, (5) Setting a fair ratio in an equity share swap, and (6) Accounting, taxation, and regulatory/legal compliance.
Only Two Sources of Value in Any Business
Warren Buffett simplifies every asset on Earth—stocks, bonds, shops, real estate—into two sources of value:
- Earnings (Periodic Cash Flows): Coupons from bonds, dividends/cash flows from equities, rent from property. Even banks lend primarily based on cash flow repayment capacity, treating collateral only as a fallback.
- Assets (Terminal / Liquidation Value): Cash realized by selling tangible and intangible assets if earnings dry up. Crucial Warning: In distress, assets often sell for far less than Balance Sheet book value, whereas liabilities must be repaid in full!
Three Broad Approaches to Valuation
| Approach | Core Idea | Who Uses It? |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Cost-Based Valuation | Value = Cost required to build/recreate the asset from scratch | Strategic corporate buyers choosing buy vs. build (requires technical engineers; rarely used by stock market investors) |
| 2. Cash Flow-Based (Intrinsic / DCF) | Value = Present Value of all future cash flows discounted at an appropriate return rate. Divided into two subtypes: (a) Risk-Neutral Valuation (adjust cash flows by realization probability, discount at Risk-Free Rate — used for Life Insurance Embedded/Appraisal Value) and (b) Real-World Valuation (estimate most likely cash flows, discount at Risk-Free Rate + Risk Premium) | Fundamental equity analysts valuing businesses from first principles |
| 3. Selling Price-Based (Relative Valuation) | Value by comparing against market multiples (P/E, P/B, EV/EBITDA) of similar peer assets | Quick, market-anchored checks of cheap vs. expensive |
Objectivity Reality Check (Section 10.12)
Is valuation 100% objective? No! Inputs like growth rates, terminal multiples, and risk premiums involve subjective judgment. Valuation is also not timeless—a regulatory shock or competitor launch can change intrinsic value overnight. Beware of huge, hyper-complex Excel models: they often create a "false impression of preciseness."
LO 10.2 DCF Mechanics: DDM, FCFE vs. FCFF, CAPM, WACC & Terminal Value
The Intuition: Start with a Simple Bond
Imagine a 10-year bond with Face Value Rs. 1,00,000 paying 9% annual coupon (Rs. 9,000/year). If investors require a 9% return (discount rate), the bond's Present Value is exactly Rs. 1,00,000.
- If prevailing interest rates rise above 9%, nobody will pay Rs. 1,00,000 for a 9% coupon → bond price FALLS below Rs. 1,00,000!
- If interest rates fall below 9% → bond price RISES above Rs. 1,00,000!
Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) applies this exact Time Value of Money logic to a business using three inputs: (1) Future stream of Free Cash Flows, (2) Timing of those cash flows, and (3) Appropriate Discount Rate. Unlike bonds, equity has a perpetual life and uncertain cash flows, making DCF sensitive to small assumption tweaks.
Three DCF Models Explained
1. Dividend Discount Model (DDM) & Gordon Growth Model
Best for mature, defensive companies paying regular, substantial dividends. If next year's expected dividend is D1, cost of equity is Ke, and dividends grow forever at a constant rate g (must satisfy g < Ke):
Fair Share Price (P) = D1 ÷ (Ke − g)
Worked Mini-Example: Hindustan Staples Ltd. expects to pay D1 = Rs. 12 next year, with Ke = 12% (0.12) and perpetual dividend growth g = 6% (0.06). Fair Value P = Rs. 12 ÷ (0.12 − 0.06) = Rs. 12 ÷ 0.06 = Rs. 200 per share.
2. Free Cash Flow to Equity (FCFE) Model
Many great growth firms (like Alphabet/Google) pay zero dividends because they reinvest profits. FCFE measures the cash left over exclusively for equity shareholders after operating needs, capex, interest, and debt movements:
FCFE = Operating Cash Flow (CFO) − Capex − Interest Paid + Net Borrowings (or − Net Debt Repayments)
- Discounted at Cost of Equity (
Ke) → directly gives Intrinsic Equity Value. - Limitation: Unless a company has a strict, transparent debt policy, guessing future net borrowings can introduce analyst bias.
3. Free Cash Flow to Firm (FCFF) Model
FCFF avoids debt-forecasting guesswork by measuring cash available to ALL capital providers (both debt and equity holders) before financing cash flows:
- Indirect Method (Most Popular):
FCFF = EBIT × (1 − Tax Rate) + Depreciation & Non-Cash Charges − Increase in Non-Cash Working Capital − Capex (Note: Add back non-cash amortization & loss on asset sale; subtract gains on asset sale and add decrease in working capital!)
- Direct (IndAS CFO) Method (Workbook Formula): Under IndAS, interest paid sits in Financing Cash Flow while CFO is after tax (including the interest tax shield), so:
FCFF = Operating Cash Flow − Capex − Tax Benefit on Interest Payments.
- Discounted at WACC → gives Value of the Firm (Enterprise Value).
- Bridge to Equity Value:
Equity Value = Firm Value (PV of FCFF) − Interest-Bearing Debt − Preferred Share Capital − Minority Interest + Surplus Cash & Short-Term Investments (Note: Enterprise Value strips out surplus cash/short-term investments not needed for core operations.)
Clean Comparison Table: FCFF vs. FCFE
| Feature | FCFF (Free Cash Flow to Firm) | FCFE (Free Cash Flow to Equity) |
|---|---|---|
| Cash Belongs To | All capital providers (Lenders + Equity holders) | Equity shareholders ONLY |
| Debt Cash Flows Included? | No (Pre-debt, pre-interest) | Yes (After interest & net borrowing/repayment) |
| Matching Discount Rate | WACC (Weighted Average Cost of Capital) | Cost of Equity (Ke) |
| DCF Output Value | Firm / Enterprise Value (adjust Debt & Cash to get Equity) | Equity Value directly |
| Best Used When | Company has changing/unclear debt policy or high leverage | Company has stable, predictable leverage policy |
Calculating Cost of Equity (CAPM) & WACC
- CAPM (Capital Asset Pricing Model):
Ke = Rf + β × (Rm − Rf)
Rf= Risk-Free Rate (e.g., 10-year Indian G-Sec yield)Rm= Expected stock market return;(Rm − Rf)= Market Risk Premium (MRP)β(Beta) = Sensitivity of stock return to market return (systematic risk);β × (Rm − Rf)= Equity Risk Premium (ERP).
- WACC (Weighted Average Cost of Capital):
WACC = [Ke × We] + [Kd × (1 − Tax Rate) × Wd]
- Why multiply
Kdby(1 − Tax)? Because interest is tax-deductible—the government effectively subsidizes part of your interest cost!
Complete Step-by-Step Worked DCF Example (CAPM → WACC → 2-Stage FCFF → Share Price)
Value Deccan Precision Ltd. (all amounts in Rs. Crore, 10 Crore shares outstanding):
- Market & Capital Inputs:
Rf = 7%,Rm = 13%(soMRP = 6%),Beta (β) = 1.2, Pre-tax Cost of DebtKd = 10%, Tax Rate= 25%. Capital Structure:75% Equity (We = 0.75)and25% Debt (Wd = 0.25). Balance Sheet: Debt= Rs. 200 Cr, Surplus Cash= Rs. 50 Cr. - Projected High-Growth FCFF (Years 1–3): Year 1 =
Rs. 100 Cr, Year 2 =Rs. 120 Cr, Year 3 =Rs. 140 Cr. Perpetual growth rate after Year 3:g = 5%(capped at or below long-term nominal GDP growth—no company can outgrow the economy forever!).
- Step 1 — CAPM Cost of Equity (
Ke):
Ke = 7% + 1.2 × (13% − 7%) = 7% + 7.2% = 14.2%
- Step 2 — Post-Tax Cost of Debt:
Kd × (1 − Tax) = 10% × (1 − 0.25) = 7.5%
- Step 3 — WACC:
WACC = (14.2% × 0.75) + (7.5% × 0.25) = 10.65% + 1.875% = 12.525% (approx. 12.5%)
- Step 4 — Present Value of Explicit FCFFs (at 12.5%):
- Year 1 PV =
100 ÷ (1.125)^1 = Rs. 88.89 Cr - Year 2 PV =
120 ÷ (1.125)^2 = Rs. 94.81 Cr - Year 3 PV =
140 ÷ (1.125)^3 = Rs. 98.33 Cr - Total Explicit PV =
88.89 + 94.81 + 98.33 = Rs. 282.03 Cr - Step 5 — Terminal Value at End of Year 3 (Gordon Growth Method):
(Alternatively, Terminal Value can be estimated using an Exit Multiple like Year 3 EBITDA × Peer EV/EBITDA.)
- Year 4 FCFF =
140 × 1.05 = Rs. 147 Cr Terminal Value (at Year 3) = 147 ÷ (0.125 − 0.05) = 147 ÷ 0.075 = Rs. 1,960 Cr- CRITICAL STEP (Discount TV Back to Today!):
PV of Terminal Value = 1,960 ÷ (1.125)^3 = 1,960 ÷ 1.4238 = Rs. 1,376.57 Cr - Step 6 — Firm Value → Intrinsic Equity Value → Fair Share Price:
Enterprise / Firm Value = 282.03 + 1,376.57 = Rs. 1,658.60 CrEquity Value = Firm Value − Debt + Surplus Cash = 1,658.60 − 200 + 50 = Rs. 1,508.60 CrIntrinsic Value per Share = Rs. 1,508.60 Cr ÷ 10 Cr shares = Rs. 150.86 per share!
Exam Takeaway: Watch out for
-0.25traps! (1) Always match cash flow to discount rate: FCFF → WACC, FCFE & Dividends → Cost of Equity (Ke)! (2) Never forget to discount Terminal Value back to Year 0, and remember perpetualgmust be less than discount rate and capped at nominal GDP growth. (3) When interest rates rise, bond prices fall. (4) Risk-Neutral Valuation discounts probability-adjusted cash flows at the risk-free rate (used for Insurance Embedded Value)—not WACC!
Test Your Understanding
Practice 48 Verified Questions for Chapter 10: Valuation Principles
Every question includes plain-English explanations for why the answer is right, why the other three options are wrong, and direct links back to each Learning Objective above.
Downloadable Study Resources
- NISM-Series-XV Valuation & Financial Ratios Formula Sheet (.txt)Download