0/30 (0%)
Module 10 · Chapter 10: Valuation Principles26 min read

Relative Valuation Multiples, Asset Multiples, SOTP & New-Age Metrics

Master earnings and asset relative valuation multiples (P/E, PEG, EV/EBITDA, EV/Sales, P/B, NAV), numerator-denominator consistency, Trading vs. Transaction multiples, SOTP, and new-age valuation pitfalls.

Official Learning Objectives Covered in This Lesson

Relative Valuation Multiples, Asset Multiples, SOTP & New-Age Metrics

Imagine you want to buy a 2-BHK flat in Pune. Rather than building a 20-year rental DCF spreadsheet, what do you naturally do first? You ask the broker: "What price per square foot did three similar flats in this society sell for last month?" That everyday shortcut is Relative Valuation—comparing what you pay (Price or EV) against what you get (Earnings, Sales, or Assets) relative to peer companies!


LO 10.3 Earnings & Asset Multiples + Numerator–Denominator Consistency

The Golden Rule of Multiples: Companion Variables & Consistency

Never declare a stock "cheap" just because its P/E or P/B looks low! Always pair every valuation multiple with its fundamental Companion Variable (the engine driving that multiple):

  • P/E Ratio ↔ paired with EPS Growth Rate & RoE
  • P/B Ratio ↔ paired with RoE
  • EV/EBITDA or EV/Capital Employed ↔ paired with RoIC / RoCE
  • Dividend Yield ↔ paired with Payout Ratio & Growth Reinvestment Avenues (a sky-high dividend yield may simply mean the firm has zero growth prospects!).

Equally critical is Numerator–Denominator Consistency—never mix an Equity numerator with a Firm-level denominator!

Valuation MultipleNumerator (Who Pays?)Denominator (Who Earns?)Consistency Check & Best Sector Use
P/E & PEGShare Price (Equity)EPS (Equity)Consistent! Profitable firms with similar debt levels
Dividend Yield / Price-to-DivShare Price (Equity)DPS (Equity)Consistent! Mature dividend-paying defensive firms
P/B & P/ABVMarket Cap (Equity)Book Equity (Equity)Consistent! Banks & NBFCs (monetary assets ≈ fair value)
P/Embedded ValueMarket Cap (Equity)Embedded Value (Equity)Consistent! Life Insurance companies
EV/EBITDAEnterprise Value (Firm)EBITDA (Firm)Consistent! Capital-intensive firms & M&A (capital-structure & depreciation neutral!)
EV/EBITEnterprise Value (Firm)EBIT (Firm)Consistent! Non-capital-intensive firms & M&A (capital-structure neutral)
EV/SalesEnterprise Value (Firm)Revenue (Firm)Consistent! Loss-making / early break-even firms (sales are never negative!)
EV/Capital EmployedEnterprise Value (Firm)Equity + Debt (Firm)Consistent! Paired directly with RoCE

(Trap Alert: Price / EBITDA or Market Cap / Sales is theoretically inconsistent because EBITDA and Sales belong to both debt and equity holders—always use EV in the numerator for EBITDA, EBIT, and Sales!)

1. Earnings-Based Valuation Multiples

A. Dividend Yield & Price-to-Dividend Ratio

Dividend Yield = DPS ÷ Current Share Price | Price/Dividend = Current Share Price ÷ DPS

  • Workbook Table Intuition: If a firm reliably pays Rs. 5 dividend, at a stock price of Rs. 50 its Dividend Yield is 10.0% (Price/Div = 10x); at Rs. 100 it is 5.0% (20x); at Rs. 200 it falls to 2.5% (40x). Compare equity yields against post-tax bond yields (e.g., a 10% bond taxed at 30% yields only 7% post-tax—so a 10% equity dividend yield with upside potential looks deeply attractive!). In bear markets, equity yields often exceed bond yields; in bull markets, they fall well below bond yields.

B. Earnings Yield & Price-to-Earnings (P/E) Ratio

  • Earnings Yield = EPS ÷ Share Price (Workbook Sample Q2: Price Rs. 195, EPS Rs. 13 → 13 ÷ 195 = 6.67%!).
  • P/E Ratio = Current Share Price ÷ EPS (exact reciprocal of Earnings Yield!). Tells you how many rupees you pay for Re. 1 of profit.
  • Trailing P/E uses historical EPS; Forward P/E uses forecasted next-year EPS (investors care most about future earnings). Higher growth or lower risk justifies a P/E premium over peers.

C. PEG Ratio (Growth-Adjusted P/E — Coined by Peter Lynch)

PEG Ratio = P/E Ratio ÷ Expected Annual EPS Growth Rate (%)

  • Rule of Thumb: PEG < 1.0 signals potential undervaluation; PEG > 1.0 signals potential overvaluation (remember: super-high growth cannot last forever!).
  • Worked Workbook Example: Company A (EPS Rs. 10, Price Rs. 120 → P/E = 12x) grows at 10%. Company B (EPS Rs. 10, Price Rs. 140 → P/E = 14x) grows at 15%.
  • PEG (A) = 12 ÷ 10 = 1.20x
  • PEG (B) = 14 ÷ 15 = 0.93x → Even with a higher P/E, Company B is cheaper once growth is factored in!

D. EV/EBITDA, EV/EBIT & EV/Sales (Worked Numerical!)

Because P/E is distorted by how much debt a company carries, acquirers prefer capital-structure neutral multiples: EV/EBITDA for capital-intensive industries (neutralizes different depreciation methods and asset ages) and EV/EBIT for other industries. For loss-making or newly break-even firms, P/E and EV/EBITDA break down—use EV/Sales (only if the firm has a credible path to profitability; otherwise use liquidation value!).

Worked Numerical Example: Computing Fair Equity Value from EV/EBITDA (Exam Favorite!)

Suppose Metro Steel Ltd. has projected EBITDA = Rs. 4,755 Lakhs, Total Debt = Rs. 1,640 Lakhs, and Cash & Equivalents = Rs. 169 Lakhs. You judge a fair EV/EBITDA multiple = 8.5x. What is the fair Equity Value?

  • Step 1 (Fair Enterprise Value): EV = Fair Multiple × EBITDA = 8.5 × Rs. 4,755 Lakhs = Rs. 40,417.5 Lakhs.
  • Step 2 (Recall EV Formula): EV = Market Cap (Equity Value) + Debt − Cash.
  • Step 3 (Rearrange for Fair Equity Value):

Fair Equity Value = EV − Debt + Cash = 40,417.5 − 1,640 + 169 = Rs. 38,946.5 Lakhs! (Notice why you subtract Debt and add back Cash—memorize this bridge cold!)

2. Asset-Based Valuation Multiples

A. Price-to-Book Value (P/B) Ratio

P/B = Market Capitalization ÷ Book Value of Equity = Share Price ÷ Book Value Per Share (BVPS)

  • Best for: Financial sector (Banks/NBFCs) because monetary loans/deposits sit close to fair value.
  • Weak for: Capital-intensive firms (historical-cost distortion) and IT/service firms (human talent & self-generated IP are missing from the Balance Sheet).
  • Worked Workbook Example: AFB Finance (50 Lakh shares, Equity Rs. 9,900 Lakhs → BVPS = Rs. 198, Price Rs. 200) vs. LKH Finance (50 Lakh shares, Equity Rs. 8,000 Lakhs → BVPS = Rs. 160, Price Rs. 175).
  • P/B (AFB) = 200 ÷ 198 = 1.01x | P/B (LKH) = 175 ÷ 160 = 1.09x → AFB is cheaper on P/B alone!
  • Mean vs. Median Warning: When comparing against an industry average, extreme outlier companies can pull up the Mean—always check both Mean and Median!

B. EV / Capital Employed Paired with RoCE (Worked Workbook Example!)

EV / Capital Employed = Enterprise Value ÷ (Total Equity + Total Debt)

  • Suppose a business has Equity Rs. 1,00,000, Debt Rs. 1,00,000 (Capital Employed = Rs. 2,00,000), Cash Nil, Market Cap Rs. 5,00,000 (EV = Rs. 6,00,000), and RoCE = 45%.
  • EV / Capital Employed = 6,00,000 ÷ 2,00,000 = 3.0x.
  • Because you pay 3× Capital Employed, your effective return drops to one-third of RoCE: 45% ÷ 3 = 15%! If you demand a minimum 20% return, the maximum multiple you can pay is 45% ÷ 20% = 2.25x (EV = Rs. 4,50,000).

C. Net Asset Value (NAV) & Specialized Multiples

  • NAV: Market Value of Assets − Liabilities (unlike Book Value, uses current market value of assets). Ideal for Real Estate, Shipping, and Aviation.
  • Specialized Multiples: Price / Embedded Value (Life Insurance—probability-adjusted PV of in-force policies), Price / Adjusted Book Value (ABV) (NBFCs—includes off-balance-sheet items at fair value), and EV / Capacity (e.g., idle steel/cement plants valued per tonne of capacity).

LO 10.4 Trading vs. Transaction Multiples, SOTP, New-Age Metrics & Valuation Wisdom

Trading Multiples vs. Transaction Multiples

  • Trading Multiples: Derived from daily stock-market prices of listed peers. Fast and abundant, but reflect temporary market mood (greed or panic)—so always check historical min, max, mean, and median ranges.
  • Transaction Multiples: Derived from actual recent M&A deals in the same industry. The NISM workbook highlights that Transaction Multiples are more authentic/relevant because real strategic buyers actually wrote cheques to acquire control at those prices!

Sum-Of-The-Parts (SOTP) Valuation

Large Indian conglomerates like ITC (Cigarettes + FMCG + Hotels + Paperboards + Agri) or Larsen & Toubro (L&T) (Engineering + IT subsidiaries + Financial Services) bundle very different businesses under one roof. Applying a single P/E ratio to the whole company makes no sense! SOTP Valuation values each vertical separately using its best-suited method and sums them up.

Quick SOTP Worked Example (Bharat Conglomerate Ltd., 10 Crore shares, Net Debt Rs. 500 Cr):

  • FMCG Division (EBITDA Rs. 400 Cr × 20x EV/EBITDA) = Rs. 8,000 Cr
  • NBFC Subsidiary (Book Value Rs. 1,000 Cr × 2.5x P/B) = Rs. 2,500 Cr
  • Real Estate Land Bank (NAV) = Rs. 1,500 Cr
  • Total Combined Value = 8,000 + 2,500 + 1,500 = Rs. 12,000 Cr → Minus Net Debt (Rs. 500 Cr) = Rs. 11,500 Cr Equity Value (Rs. 1,150/share).

New-Age Economy Valuation Metrics (E-Commerce & Tech)

For fast-growing tech platforms (e.g., Zomato, WhatsApp, LinkedIn, Facebook), traditional P/E often fails early on, so markets cite operating metrics like eyeballs, page views, footfalls, ARPU, GMV (Gross Merchandise Value), number of users, or transaction count.

  • Buffett's Reality Check: Every user and click must eventually convert into real profits and cash flows for owners. Without a clear path to profitability, valuations rest purely on a "storyline" and finding the next buyer—and collapse like a house of cards when sentiment turns (just like the 2000–2001 Dot-Com Crash!).

Nine Essential Valuation Considerations (Section 10.13 Checklist)

  1. High earning power → Book Value matters less; Low earning power → Book Value becomes critical.
  2. Since a share is part-ownership, value the entire business first, then divide by shares.
  3. Enterprise Value (EV)—not Market Cap—is the true takeover value of a firm for a private owner.
  4. P/E of a leveraged firm can be deceptive—always check debt levels!
  5. Always use Consolidated financials, not just Standalone.
  6. Focus on RoE rather than EPS alone—EPS ignores how much retained earnings were ploughed back to buy that growth.
  7. Leverage boosts RoE, but excessive leverage adds bankruptcy risk.
  8. Differentiate RoCE from RoE: RoCE reflects true operational return on total capital, whereas RoE can be artificially inflated by high debt.
  9. RoCE and RoE should be closely knit—any wide gap between the two is an immediate trigger for deeper investigation!

Exam Takeaway: Watch out for -0.25 traps! (1) Always verify Numerator–Denominator Consistency (EV/EBITDA, EV/Sales, P/E, P/B). (2) When converting Fair EV → Fair Equity Value, always do EV − Debt + Cash (many students reverse the signs!). (3) P/B is best for Banks/NBFCs, P/Embedded Value for Life Insurance, NAV for Real Estate/Shipping/Aviation, and EV/Sales for loss-making firms with a turnaround path. (4) Transaction Multiples are considered more authentic than Trading Multiples, and a wide gap between RoCE and RoE demands immediate investigation!

Test Your Understanding

Practice 48 Verified Questions for Chapter 10: Valuation Principles

Every question includes plain-English explanations for why the answer is right, why the other three options are wrong, and direct links back to each Learning Objective above.

Track your progressMark this lesson complete to update your course checklist.